PCGS Price Guide: Buffalo Nickel

Prices in US Dollars $ Change
Exchange Rate Updated On 7/9/2025 7:06 AM
Buffalo Nickel, MS PCGS Photograde
PCGS No Description Desig 4 12 40 60 63 64 65 66 67 68
PCGS No Description Desig 4 12 40 60 63 64 65 66 67 68
Complete Set - Date MS
+ 		144
- 		▼236
- 		555
- 		2,076
- 		4,149
4,807 		5,974
7,694 		11,099
14,580 		24,475
39,230 		140,395
416,850 		-
Complete Set-Date & Mint Mark MS
+ 		1,276
- 		▼2,560
- 		9,050
- 		31,960
- 		59,553
70,839 		88,204
120,054 		310,434
616,375 		- - -
Complete Set - with Major Varieties MS
+ 		8,732
- 		▼17,808
- 		46,463
- 		172,607
- 		349,203
- 		- - - - -
Type 1, "FIVE CENTS" On Raised Ground, MS
PCGS No Description Desig 4 12 40 60 63 64 65 66 67 68
PCGS No Description Desig 4 12 40 60 63 64 65 66 67 68
3914 Type MS
+ 		15
- 		20
- 		29
- 		65
- 		110
135 		160
185 		235
275 		400
675 		1,325
2,400 		9,500
80,000
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, MS
PCGS No Description Desig 4 12 40 60 63 64 65 66 67 68
PCGS No Description Desig 4 12 40 60 63 64 65 66 67 68
3919 Type MS
+ 		3
- 		5
- 		8
- 		32
- 		42
46 		52
62 		72
85 		100
140 		260
850 		8,500
30,000
3922 1913-D Type 2 MS
+ 		125
- 		175
- 		240
- 		375
- 		475
525 		575
850 		1,275
1,850 		3,750
5,500 		18,000
36,500 		52,500
-
3923 1913-S Type 2 MS
+ 		225
- 		380
- 		550
- 		1,150
- 		1,650
1,800 		2,000
2,250 		3,150
4,000 		7,250
18,500 		40,000
60,000 		-
3924 1914 MS
+ 		27
- 		36
- 		48
- 		105
- 		175
220 		325
400 		475
650 		1,550
1,750 		9,000
32,500 		-
3925 1914-D MS
+ 		90
- 		140
- 		260
- 		525
- 		660
700 		900
1,050 		1,800
2,250 		3,600
4,750 		22,500
32,500 		-
3926 1914-S MS
+ 		37
- 		60
- 		125
- 		260
- 		450
550 		725
1,350 		2,850
4,500 		7,750
18,000 		38,500
75,000 		-
3933 1916-S MS
+ 		15
- 		30
- 		110
- 		250
- 		475
675 		1,100
1,250 		2,750
4,250 		8,000
16,000 		42,500
70,000 		-
3938 1918-D MS
+ 		35
- 		80
- 		265
- 		650
- 		1,400
1,500 		1,700
2,500 		4,000
5,000 		9,500
25,000 		40,000
- 		-
3950 1923-S MS
+ 		12
- 		45
- 		260
- 		700
- 		1,125
1,400 		2,000
2,250 		6,500
14,500 		47,500
75,000 		- -
3951 1924 MS
+ 		4
- 		8
- 		30
- 		115
- 		400
450 		525
675 		1,000
1,250 		3,500
5,250 		22,500
40,000 		-
3952 1924-D MS
+ 		15
- 		50
- 		250
- 		700
- 		1,375
1,600 		1,750
2,650 		5,000
6,750 		13,500
- 		- -
3953 1924-S MS
+ 		25
- 		110
- 		775
- 		4,000
- 		6,500
8,500 		9,500
11,250 		12,500
20,000 		55,000
125,000 		- -
3954 1925 MS
+ 		4
- 		8
- 		25
- 		65
- 		210
250 		300
350 		525
750 		1,450
2,250 		4,250
21,000 		-
3959 1926-S MS
+ 		40
- 		95
- 		1,125
- 		5,500
- 		11,500
13,000 		16,500
21,000 		130,000
260,000 		- - -
3960 1927 MS
+ 		3
- 		6
- 		18
- 		55
- 		105
150 		250
315 		375
425 		575
825 		3,350
18,500 		37,500
-
3963 1928 MS
+ 		3
- 		6
- 		20
- 		55
- 		120
145 		200
275 		325
475 		950
1,250 		5,000
16,500 		-
3964 1928-D MS
+ 		3
- 		7
- 		50
- 		85
- 		225
250 		275
325 		550
950 		4,750
6,500 		30,000
- 		-
3966 1929 MS
+ 		3
- 		6
- 		15
- 		50
- 		100
125 		165
225 		340
525 		650
1,250 		9,500
50,000 		-
3967 1929-D MS
+ 		3
- 		5
- 		40
- 		100
- 		210
255 		300
550 		1,050
1,650 		2,100
6,250 		18,000
30,000 		-
3972 1934 MS
+ 		3
- 		5
- 		15
- 		65
- 		125
155 		185
215 		250
360 		650
1,050 		3,850
11,000 		-
3973 1934-D MS
+ 		3
- 		6
- 		30
- 		100
- 		200
235 		260
300 		475
850 		2,350
20,000 		30,000
- 		-
3980 1937 MS
+ 		3
- 		5
- 		8
- 		32
- 		42
46 		52
62 		72
85 		100
140 		260
850 		8,500
30,000
3981 1937-D MS
+ 		3
- 		5
- 		8
- 		32
- 		42
46 		55
75 		110
125 		150
275 		750
2,250 		20,000
30,000
3983 1937-S MS
+ 		3
- 		5
- 		8
- 		32
- 		42
46 		55
75 		110
135 		200
250 		750
6,250 		17,500
-
3984 1938-D MS
+ 		3
- 		5
- 		8
- 		32
- 		42
46 		52
62 		72
85 		100
140 		260
850 		8,500
30,000
Buffalo Nickel, PR PCGS Photograde
PCGS No Description Desig 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69
PCGS No Description Desig 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69
Complete Set PR
+ 		6,800
- 		7,425
- 		8,600
9,500 		11,400
12,475 		14,950
17,200 		20,450
23,550 		29,200
36,600 		46,950
62,750 		238,000
- 		-
Type 1, "FIVE CENTS" On Raised Ground, PR
PCGS No Description Desig 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69
PCGS No Description Desig 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69
3986 Type PR
+ 		900
- 		975
- 		1,125
1,225 		1,650
1,850 		2,250
3,150 		4,250
4,850 		6,750
7,500 		8,750
12,500 		100,000
- 		-
3988 1913 Type 1 PR
+ 		900
- 		975
- 		1,125
1,225 		1,650
1,850 		2,250
3,150 		4,250
4,850 		6,750
7,500 		8,750
12,500 		100,000
- 		-
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, PR
PCGS No Description Desig 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69
PCGS No Description Desig 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69
3989 Type PR
+ 		775
- 		850
- 		950
1,025 		1,125
1,200 		1,250
1,300 		1,350
1,450 		1,600
2,000 		2,250
3,750 		7,500
16,500 		85,000
-
83989 Type CAM
+ 		- - 1,900
2,050 		2,400
2,650 		3,250
4,000 		6,500
8,750 		11,500
14,000 		18,500
27,500 		- -
3990 1913 Type 2 PR
+ 		775
- 		850
- 		950
1,025 		1,125
1,200 		1,600
1,950 		2,750
2,900 		3,250
4,000 		6,000
7,250 		32,500
45,000 		-
3991 1914 PR
+ 		775
- 		850
- 		950
1,025 		1,250
1,325 		1,500
1,750 		2,100
2,750 		4,250
4,750 		5,750
7,750 		22,500
45,000 		-
3992 1915 PR
+ 		775
- 		850
- 		975
1,150 		1,500
1,750 		2,250
2,400 		2,600
3,150 		3,850
4,750 		5,250
6,500 		35,000
62,500 		-
3993 1916 PR
+ 		1,250
- 		1,350
- 		1,750
2,000 		2,500
2,750 		3,500
3,850 		4,250
5,000 		5,750
8,500 		12,500
15,000 		22,500
50,000 		-
3994 1936 Satin PR
+ 		775
- 		850
- 		950
1,025 		1,125
1,200 		1,350
1,500 		1,800
2,000 		2,150
2,500 		2,850
3,750 		7,500
16,500 		85,000
-
3995 1936 Brilliant PR
+ 		775
- 		850
- 		950
1,025 		1,125
1,200 		1,250
1,300 		1,350
1,450 		1,600
2,600 		3,600
6,250 		10,500
55,000 		95,000
-
3996 1937 PR
+ 		775
- 		850
- 		950
1,025 		1,125
1,200 		1,250
1,300 		1,350
1,450 		1,600
2,000 		2,250
3,750 		7,500
20,000 		95,000
-
83996 1937 CAM
+ 		- - 1,900
2,050 		2,400
2,650 		3,250
4,000 		6,500
8,750 		11,500
14,000 		18,500
27,500 		- -
Buffalo Nickel, SP PCGS Photograde
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, SP
PCGS No Description Desig 4 12 40 60 63 64 65 66 67 68
PCGS No Description Desig 4 12 40 60 63 64 65 66 67 68
3987 1927 Special Strike SP
+ 		- - - - - - 95,000
110,000 		125,000
- 		- -