1921 Canada Five Cents A Grail for Collectors

1921 Canada silver five-cent coin. Click image to enlarge.

Prior to 1921, Canadian five-cent coins were struck not from nickel but from silver. The little silver five-cent coins weighed just 1.17 grams and had a slight diameter of just 15.5 millimeters. However, the rising cost of silver pushed the Royal Mint to make some adjustments in metal compositions. This subsequently led to lowering the purity of silver Canadian coins from sterling (92.5%, or .925 fine) to 80% (.800 fine) silver, a move directly affecting the five-cent coin.

The five-cent coin was produced in .800-fine silver for a short time in 1921, with about 2.5 million examples bearing the 1921 date. However, within months mint officials decided that it would be more cost effective to produce the five-cent coin from pure nickel. The move was made official on January 2, 1922, with an order calling for the melting of the silver 1921 five-cent coins. Of the 2.5 million silver 1921 five-cent coins, perhaps only 100 to 250 survived. The 1921 silver five-cent coins are now highly coveted rarities that rank as one of the top collectibles of the entire Canadian numismatic catalog.

Many of the survivors escaped into circulation, yet a very small number escaped the wear and tear of use in daily commerce. Any 1921 Canadian five cents sell for prices ranging from about $5,000 for pieces grading VG8 to roughly $8,500 in F12. You can expect to pay some $15,000 for an example in XF40, and in AU50 prices climb to $15,000 to $20,000. In Mint State grades, prices sail clear above $50,000, and at least one has garnered over $100,000. On January 3, 2010, Heritage Auctions sold a PCGS MS67 specimen that traded hands for an incredible $115,000.