PCGS Price Guide: Buffalo Nickel

Prices in Euros € (1 USD = 0.89 EUR) Change
Exchange Rate Updated On 10/14/2026 1:59 PM
Buffalo Nickel, MS PCGS Photograde
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
Complete Set - Date MS
+ 		2,138
- 		2,502
2,879 		3,684
4,256 		5,215
6,639 		9,238
12,384 		21,271
33,954 		117,342
366,858 		- - -
Complete Set-Date & Mint Mark MS
+ 		32,905
- 		38,555
43,582 		52,112
61,654 		77,510
104,895 		267,930
538,779 		- - - - -
Complete Set - with Major Varieties MS
+ 		175,933
- 		218,660
243,498 		309,678
- 		- - - - - - -
Type 1, "FIVE CENTS" On Raised Ground, MS
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3914 Type MS
+ 		76
- 		85
98 		111
129 		156
174 		209
245 		334
601 		1,179
2,225 		8,010
71,200 		- -
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, MS
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3919 Type MS
+ 		31
- 		33
35 		37
41 		49
58 		67
80 		93
134 		254
757 		7,565
24,475 		- -
3922 1913-D Type 2 MS
+ 		347
- 		378
401 		423
467 		512
757 		1,135
1,558 		3,115
4,450 		14,685
32,485 		46,725
- 		- -
3923 1913-S Type 2 MS
+ 		1,113
- 		1,202
1,291 		1,469
1,602 		1,780
2,003 		2,893
3,783 		6,453
16,465 		35,600
57,850 		- - -
3924 1914 MS
+ 		98
- 		102
111 		156
196 		289
356 		423
579 		1,380
1,558 		7,343
28,925 		- - -
3925 1914-D MS
+ 		498
- 		534
556 		587
623 		734
868 		1,602
2,003 		3,115
4,005 		19,135
28,925 		- - -
3926 1914-S MS
+ 		245
- 		267
334 		423
490 		645
1,202 		2,537
4,005 		6,898
16,020 		34,265
66,750 		- - -
3933 1916-S MS
+ 		289
- 		312
334 		423
601 		979
1,113 		2,314
3,783 		6,675
13,350 		37,825
62,300 		- - -
3938 1918-D MS
+ 		757
- 		801
935 		1,246
1,335 		1,513
2,225 		3,560
4,450 		8,455
22,250 		35,600
- 		- - -
3950 1923-S MS
+ 		668
- 		801
890 		1,001
1,246 		1,780
2,003 		5,563
12,905 		42,275
66,750 		- - - -
3951 1924 MS
+ 		142
- 		178
223 		312
356 		467
579 		846
1,113 		3,115
4,450 		20,025
35,600 		- - -
3952 1924-D MS
+ 		668
- 		757
890 		1,224
1,424 		1,558
2,359 		4,228
5,118 		11,570
24,475 		- - - -
3953 1924-S MS
+ 		4,228
- 		4,673
4,895 		5,118
6,453 		8,233
9,345 		10,680
17,800 		42,275
111,250 		- - - -
3954 1925 MS
+ 		71
- 		89
111 		187
214 		245
280 		378
579 		1,224
2,003 		3,783
18,690 		- - -
3959 1926-S MS
+ 		6,008
- 		8,010
8,900 		10,235
11,570 		14,685
18,690 		115,700
231,400 		- - - - -
3960 1927 MS
+ 		55
- 		64
73 		93
134 		191
245 		312
378 		512
645 		2,448
16,465 		33,375
- 		- -
3963 1928 MS
+ 		53
- 		58
76 		107
129 		178
245 		289
423 		779
1,068 		4,005
14,685 		- - -
3964 1928-D MS
+ 		80
- 		111
147 		200
223 		245
289 		490
846 		3,783
6,008 		26,700
- 		- - -
3966 1929 MS
+ 		58
- 		67
76 		89
111 		147
200 		303
467 		601
1,202 		7,788
44,500 		- - -
3967 1929-D MS
+ 		111
- 		134
151 		187
227 		267
490 		935
1,558 		2,003
6,230 		16,020
26,700 		- - -
3972 1934 MS
+ 		62
- 		67
76 		111
138 		165
191 		223
320 		556
779 		3,115
8,900 		- - -
3973 1934-D MS
+ 		98
- 		111
134 		178
209 		231
267 		423
757 		2,225
13,350 		22,250
- 		- - -
3980 1937 MS
+ 		31
- 		33
35 		37
41 		49
58 		67
80 		93
134 		254
757 		7,565
24,475 		- -
3981 1937-D MS
+ 		31
- 		33
35 		37
41 		49
67 		98
111 		134
245 		556
1,602 		17,800
24,475 		- -
3983 1937-S MS
+ 		31
- 		33
35 		37
41 		49
67 		98
120 		178
200 		623
4,673 		14,240
- 		- -
Buffalo Nickel, PR PCGS Photograde
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
Complete Set PR
+ 		6,675
- 		7,810
8,700 		10,413
11,325 		13,506
15,308 		18,112
20,470 		25,232
32,263 		41,697
54,290 		203,810
- 		- -
Type 1, "FIVE CENTS" On Raised Ground, PR
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3986 Type PR
+ 		935
- 		1,046
1,224 		1,558
1,780 		2,225
2,893 		3,783
4,317 		6,008
6,675 		7,788
11,125 		89,000
- 		- -
3988 1913 Type 1 PR
+ 		935
- 		1,046
1,224 		1,558
1,780 		2,225
2,893 		3,783
4,317 		6,008
6,675 		7,788
11,125 		89,000
- 		- -
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, PR
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3989 Type PR
+ 		757
- 		868
935 		1,046
1,090 		1,135
1,157 		1,202
1,246 		1,335
1,780 		2,003
3,115 		5,785
12,460 		66,750
- 		-
83989 Type CAM
+ 		- 1,691
1,825 		2,136
2,359 		2,893
3,560 		5,785
8,010 		11,125
13,350 		16,465
24,475 		- - -
3990 1913 Type 2 PR
+ 		757
- 		868
935 		1,046
1,090 		1,424
1,736 		2,448
2,581 		2,893
3,783 		5,563
6,675 		28,925
40,050 		- -
3991 1914 PR
+ 		757
- 		868
935 		1,113
1,179 		1,335
1,558 		1,869
2,448 		3,783
4,228 		5,118
6,898 		18,690
40,050 		- -
3992 1915 PR
+ 		757
- 		868
1,024 		1,335
1,558 		2,003
2,092 		2,225
2,670 		3,338
4,228 		4,673
5,563 		26,700
46,725 		- -
3993 1916 PR
+ 		1,202
- 		1,558
1,780 		2,225
2,448 		3,115
3,427 		3,783
4,228 		4,673
7,120 		11,125
13,350 		20,025
44,500 		- -
3994 1936 Satin PR
+ 		757
- 		868
935 		1,046
1,090 		1,135
1,291 		1,602
1,736 		1,869
2,225 		2,537
3,115 		5,785
12,460 		66,750
- 		-
3995 1936 Brilliant PR
+ 		757
- 		868
935 		1,046
1,090 		1,135
1,157 		1,202
1,246 		1,335
2,225 		2,893
4,450 		8,900
48,950 		84,550
- 		-
3996 1937 PR
+ 		757
- 		868
935 		1,046
1,090 		1,135
1,157 		1,202
1,246 		1,335
1,780 		2,003
3,115 		5,785
17,800 		84,550
- 		-
83996 1937 CAM
+ 		- 1,691
1,825 		2,136
2,359 		2,893
3,560 		5,785
8,010 		11,125
13,350 		16,465
24,475 		- - -
Buffalo Nickel, SP PCGS Photograde
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, SP
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3987 1927 Special Strike SP
+ 		- - - - 84,550
97,900 		111,250
- 		- - - -