PCGS Price Guide: Buffalo Nickel

Prices in Japanese Yen ¥ (1 USD = 158.45 JPY) Change
Exchange Rate Updated On 10/14/2026 1:59 PM
Buffalo Nickel, MS PCGS Photograde
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
Complete Set - Date MS
+ 		380,597
- 		445,403
512,586 		655,825
757,708 		928,517
1,182,037 		1,644,711
2,204,832 		3,786,955
6,044,868 		20,890,840
65,313,090 		- - -
Complete Set-Date & Mint Mark MS
+ 		5,858,213
- 		6,864,054
7,758,980 		9,277,723
10,976,465 		13,799,410
18,674,917 		47,700,580
95,920,877 		- - - - -
Complete Set - with Major Varieties MS
+ 		31,321,921
- 		38,928,788
43,350,811 		55,133,153
- 		- - - - - - -
Type 1, "FIVE CENTS" On Raised Ground, MS
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3914 Type MS
+ 		13,468
- 		15,053
17,430 		19,806
22,975 		27,729
30,898 		37,236
43,574 		59,419
106,954 		209,946
396,125 		1,426,050
12,676,000 		- -
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, MS
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3919 Type MS
+ 		5,546
- 		5,863
6,180 		6,655
7,289 		8,715
10,299 		11,884
14,260 		16,637
23,768 		45,158
134,683 		1,346,825
4,357,375 		- -
3922 1913-D Type 2 MS
+ 		61,795
- 		67,341
71,303 		75,264
83,186 		91,109
134,683 		202,024
277,288 		554,575
792,250 		2,614,425
5,783,425 		8,318,625
- 		- -
3923 1913-S Type 2 MS
+ 		198,063
- 		213,907
229,752 		261,442
285,210 		316,900
356,513 		514,962
673,413 		1,148,763
2,931,325 		6,338,000
10,299,250 		- - -
3924 1914 MS
+ 		17,430
- 		18,222
19,806 		27,729
34,859 		51,496
63,380 		75,264
102,992 		245,597
277,288 		1,307,213
5,149,625 		- - -
3925 1914-D MS
+ 		88,732
- 		95,070
99,031 		104,577
110,915 		130,721
154,489 		285,210
356,513 		554,575
713,025 		3,406,675
5,149,625 		- - -
3926 1914-S MS
+ 		43,574
- 		47,535
59,419 		75,264
87,148 		114,876
213,907 		451,582
713,025 		1,227,988
2,852,100 		6,100,325
11,883,750 		- - -
3933 1916-S MS
+ 		51,496
- 		55,457
59,419 		75,264
106,954 		174,295
198,063 		411,970
673,413 		1,188,375
2,376,750 		6,734,125
11,091,500 		- - -
3938 1918-D MS
+ 		134,683
- 		142,605
166,373 		221,830
237,675 		269,365
396,125 		633,800
792,250 		1,505,275
3,961,250 		6,338,000
- 		- - -
3950 1923-S MS
+ 		118,837
- 		142,605
158,450 		178,256
221,830 		316,900
356,513 		990,312
2,297,525 		7,526,375
11,883,750 		- - - -
3951 1924 MS
+ 		25,352
- 		31,690
39,613 		55,457
63,380 		83,186
102,992 		150,528
198,063 		554,575
792,250 		3,565,125
6,338,000 		- - -
3952 1924-D MS
+ 		118,837
- 		134,683
158,450 		217,869
253,520 		277,288
419,892 		752,638
911,087 		2,059,850
4,357,375 		- - - -
3953 1924-S MS
+ 		752,638
- 		831,862
871,475 		911,087
1,148,763 		1,465,663
1,663,725 		1,901,400
3,169,000 		7,526,375
19,806,250 		- - - -
3954 1925 MS
+ 		12,676
- 		15,845
19,806 		33,275
38,028 		43,574
49,912 		67,341
102,992 		217,869
356,513 		673,413
3,327,450 		- - -
3959 1926-S MS
+ 		1,069,538
- 		1,426,050
1,584,500 		1,822,175
2,059,850 		2,614,425
3,327,450 		20,598,500
41,197,000 		- - - - -
3960 1927 MS
+ 		9,824
- 		11,408
12,993 		16,637
23,768 		34,067
43,574 		55,457
67,341 		91,109
114,876 		435,737
2,931,325 		5,941,875
- 		- -
3963 1928 MS
+ 		9,507
- 		10,299
13,468 		19,014
22,975 		31,690
43,574 		51,496
75,264 		138,644
190,140 		713,025
2,614,425 		- - -
3964 1928-D MS
+ 		14,260
- 		19,806
26,144 		35,651
39,613 		43,574
51,496 		87,148
150,528 		673,413
1,069,538 		4,753,500
- 		- - -
3966 1929 MS
+ 		10,299
- 		11,884
13,468 		15,845
19,806 		26,144
35,651 		53,873
83,186 		106,954
213,907 		1,386,438
7,922,500 		- - -
3967 1929-D MS
+ 		19,806
- 		23,768
26,936 		33,275
40,405 		47,535
87,148 		166,373
277,288 		356,513
1,109,150 		2,852,100
4,753,500 		- - -
3972 1934 MS
+ 		11,092
- 		11,884
13,468 		19,806
24,560 		29,313
34,067 		39,613
57,042 		99,031
138,644 		554,575
1,584,500 		- - -
3973 1934-D MS
+ 		17,430
- 		19,806
23,768 		31,690
37,236 		41,197
47,535 		75,264
134,683 		396,125
2,376,750 		3,961,250
- 		- - -
3980 1937 MS
+ 		5,546
- 		5,863
6,180 		6,655
7,289 		8,715
10,299 		11,884
14,260 		16,637
23,768 		45,158
134,683 		1,346,825
4,357,375 		- -
3981 1937-D MS
+ 		5,546
- 		5,863
6,180 		6,655
7,289 		8,715
11,884 		17,430
19,806 		23,768
43,574 		99,031
285,210 		3,169,000
4,357,375 		- -
3983 1937-S MS
+ 		5,546
- 		5,863
6,180 		6,655
7,289 		8,715
11,884 		17,430
21,391 		31,690
35,651 		110,915
831,862 		2,535,200
- 		- -
Buffalo Nickel, PR PCGS Photograde
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
Complete Set PR
+ 		1,188,375
- 		1,390,399
1,548,849 		1,853,865
2,016,276 		2,404,479
2,725,340 		3,224,458
3,644,350 		4,492,058
5,743,813 		7,423,382
9,665,450 		36,285,050
- 		- -
Type 1, "FIVE CENTS" On Raised Ground, PR
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3986 Type PR
+ 		166,373
- 		186,179
217,869 		277,288
316,900 		396,125
514,962 		673,413
768,483 		1,069,538
1,188,375 		1,386,438
1,980,625 		15,845,000
- 		- -
3988 1913 Type 1 PR
+ 		166,373
- 		186,179
217,869 		277,288
316,900 		396,125
514,962 		673,413
768,483 		1,069,538
1,188,375 		1,386,438
1,980,625 		15,845,000
- 		- -
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, PR
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3989 Type PR
+ 		134,683
- 		154,489
166,373 		186,179
194,101 		202,024
205,985 		213,907
221,830 		237,675
316,900 		356,513
554,575 		1,029,925
2,218,300 		11,883,750
- 		-
83989 Type CAM
+ 		- 301,055
324,823 		380,280
419,892 		514,962
633,800 		1,029,925
1,426,050 		1,980,625
2,376,750 		2,931,325
4,357,375 		- - -
3990 1913 Type 2 PR
+ 		134,683
- 		154,489
166,373 		186,179
194,101 		253,520
308,978 		435,737
459,505 		514,962
673,413 		990,312
1,188,375 		5,149,625
7,130,250 		- -
3991 1914 PR
+ 		134,683
- 		154,489
166,373 		198,063
209,946 		237,675
277,288 		332,745
435,737 		673,413
752,638 		911,087
1,227,988 		3,327,450
7,130,250 		- -
3992 1915 PR
+ 		134,683
- 		154,489
182,218 		237,675
277,288 		356,513
372,358 		396,125
475,350 		594,188
752,638 		831,862
990,312 		4,753,500
8,318,625 		- -
3993 1916 PR
+ 		213,907
- 		277,288
316,900 		396,125
435,737 		554,575
610,033 		673,413
752,638 		831,862
1,267,600 		1,980,625
2,376,750 		3,565,125
7,922,500 		- -
3994 1936 Satin PR
+ 		134,683
- 		154,489
166,373 		186,179
194,101 		202,024
229,752 		285,210
308,978 		332,745
396,125 		451,582
554,575 		1,029,925
2,218,300 		11,883,750
- 		-
3995 1936 Brilliant PR
+ 		134,683
- 		154,489
166,373 		186,179
194,101 		202,024
205,985 		213,907
221,830 		237,675
396,125 		514,962
792,250 		1,584,500
8,714,750 		15,052,750
- 		-
3996 1937 PR
+ 		134,683
- 		154,489
166,373 		186,179
194,101 		202,024
205,985 		213,907
221,830 		237,675
316,900 		356,513
554,575 		1,029,925
3,169,000 		15,052,750
- 		-
83996 1937 CAM
+ 		- 301,055
324,823 		380,280
419,892 		514,962
633,800 		1,029,925
1,426,050 		1,980,625
2,376,750 		2,931,325
4,357,375 		- - -
Buffalo Nickel, SP PCGS Photograde
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, SP
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
PCGS No Description Desig 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70
3987 1927 Special Strike SP
+ 		- - - - 15,052,750
17,429,500 		19,806,250
- 		- - - -