1889 $1 PR(PCGS#7324)

December 2025 Showcase Auction - The James A. Stack, Sr. Collection Part I

Auctioneer

Stack's Bowers

Lot Number

20014

Grade

PR63

Price

7,800

Lot Description

The Philadelphia Mint's output of Proof silver dollars in 1889 amounted to 811 coins. Writing in <em>The Morgan and Peace Dollar Textbook</em>, Wayne Miller states:<p><em>Although some 1889 proof dollars evidence the flat strike just described [for the preceding issue], this problem is not as prevalent as with the 1888 proof. Nevertheless, it is very frustrating to examine a proof which would otherwise be a full gem coin except for the lack of high-point detail.</em><p>Using strike as the only criteria for a moment, this coin from the James A. Stack, Sr. Collection is a real gem of a Proof 1889 silver dollar. It is fully defined throughout the design, even in the centers, where every strand of hair over Liberty's ear and feather on the eagle's breast is crisply delineated. Additionally, both sides present a brilliant finish that shines forth powerfully with only light toning in iridescent reddish-gold and pale sandy-silver. Given the presence of wispy hairlines and some haziness clouding the finish, the graders at PCGS returned an accurate Proof-63 grade. With its superior strike quality and strong eye appeal, especially when viewed with direct lighting, this coin offers exceptional value for a Morgan dollar certified as Proof-63. The word <em>opportunity</em> comes readily to the fore here, as astute bidders will certainly recognize.