1864 $2.50, DCAM PR (PCGS#97890)
Summer 2026 Global Showcase Auction U.S. Coins
- Auctioneer
- Stack's Bowers
- Lot Number
- 2226
- Grade
- PR65DCAM
- Price
- 79,300
- Lot Description
- Here we go with another marvelous coin, a landmark Gem Ultra Cameo Proof example of a quarter eagle rarity. Bright, vivid medium gold surfaces deliver outstanding eye appeal. The fields are deeply reflective with a subtle "orange peel" texture discernible with the aid of a loupe. The devices, however, are set apart with a billowy, frosty texture, and they also display razor sharp striking detail. A beautiful specimen, and sure to catch the eye of advanced collectors of Proof Liberty Head gold.<p>The Philadelphia Mint stepped up Proof quarter eagle production in 1864, when it delivered 50 specimens on February 11. Such an increase of nearly twofold over the 30-piece mintage achieved in 1863 might seem unusual as the Civil War continued to rage. Writing in his excellent reference <em>United States Proof Coin</em>s (2018 volume), however, John W. Dannreuther makes a convincing argument for the Mint's optimism in 1864 being based on strong sales for the Proof-only 1863 Philadelphia Mint issue. Whatever the motivation for the higher mintage, the Proof 1864 certainly did not perform as well with contemporary collectors and only 14 to 16 specimens are believed extant in all grades, as compared to 18 to 22 survivors for the Proof 1863. The Mint would adjust its expectations again in 1865, in which year Proof quarter eagle coinage return to a more appropriate level for the era at 25 pieces produced.<p>Two Proof 1864 quarter eagles are permanently impounded in the collections of the Smithsonian Institution and American Numismatic Society. Among those in private hands, this is only the second that we have offered since our (American Numismatic Rarities') Kennywood Collection sale of January 2005. Given that the circulation strike 1864 Philadelphia Mint is also a key date rarity with just 2,774 coins struck (there is no 1864-S $2.50 issue), demand for this Gem Ultra Cameo specimen will come from both quarter eagle date collectors and Proof Liberty Head gold enthusiasts, as well as Civil War aficionados. Only the strongest bid and most aggressive strategy will prevail here.
View the Original Auction