PCGS Price Guide: Gold Buffalos

Prices in US Dollars $

Exchange Rate Updated On 6/3/2026 4:59 PM

Gold Buffalos, MS

$50 Gold Buffalos, MS

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

136

Type

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

9999

2006 $50 .9999 Fine

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

149121

2007 $50 .9999 Fine

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

149122

2007 $50 FS .9999 Fine

MS
+

4,860
-

4,870
-

5,215
-

▼6,111
-

393327

2008 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,925
-

4,950
-

4,985
-

5,375
-

▼6,236
-

413934

2009 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

418863

2010 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

506883

2011 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,111
-

511521

2012 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

516502

2013 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,136
-

521929

2014 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

535963

2015 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

593803

2016 $50 Am. Buffalo 10th Anniv. .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

616693

2017 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,136
-

619675

2017 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold First Day of Issue

MS
+

5,150
-

658586

2018 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

688647

2019 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,186
-

811469

2020 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

844923

2021 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,236
-

897009

2022 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,850
-

4,860
-

5,200
-

▼6,086
-

915084

2023 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,860
-

5,200
-

935925

2024 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,950
-

5,000
-

973239

2025 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

MS
+

4,950
-

5,000
-

1005198

2026 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold First Day of Issue Stephanie Sabin

MS
+

17,500
-

1005203

2026 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold First Day of Issue Paul C. Balan

MS
+

17,500
-

1007448

2026 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold First Day of Issue David Hall

MS
+

18,500
-

1012842

2026 $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold David Hall PCGS

MS
+

18,500
-

$5 Gold Buffalos, MS

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

132

Type

MS
+

850
-

860
-

870
-

880
-

890
-

900
-

960
-

1,050
-

$10 Gold Buffalos, MS

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

133

Type

MS
+

1,650
-

1,660
-

1,670
-

1,680
-

1,690
-

1,750
-

1,800
-

$25 Gold Buffalos, MS

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

135

Type

MS
+

1,610
-

1,620
-

1,700
-

1,750
-

Gold Buffalos, PR

$50 Gold Buffalos, PR

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

142

Type

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,083
-

9990

2006-W $50 .9999 Fine

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,168
-

▼5,483
-

149583

2007-W $50 .9999 Fine

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,083
-

526323

2008-W $10 American Buffalo First Strike .9999 Fine Gold Moy Signature

DCAM
+

8,400
-

525423

2008-W $50 American Buffalo First Strike .9999 Fine Gold Moy Signature

DCAM
+

19,500
-

393329

2008-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,083
-

523194

2009-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold Moy UHR Signature

DCAM
+

5,000
-

524980

2009-W $50 American Buffalo First Strike .9999 Fine Gold Moy Signature

DCAM
+

6,000
-

414463

2009-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,133
-

418865

2010-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,218
-

▼5,333
-

506885

2011-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,133
-

524979

2011-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold Moy Signature

DCAM
+

7,900
-

511523

2012-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,183
-

520050

2013-W $50 American Buffalo Rev PR 100th Anniversary .9999 Fine Gold

PR
+

5,400
-

5,410
-

5,485
-

5,650
-

518205

2013-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,053
-

▼5,058
-

▼5,068
-

▼5,088
-

▼5,093
-

▼5,133
-

527904

2014-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,083
-

528493

2014-W $50 American Buffalo First Strike .9999 Fine Gold Moy Signature

DCAM
+

▲5,375
-

541973

2015-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,333
-

593786

2016-W $50 Am. Buffalo 10th Anniv. .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,083
-

619672

2017-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,233
-

675284

2018-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,003
-

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,233
-

722804

2019-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,008
-

▼5,013
-

▼5,043
-

▼5,458
-

811472

2020-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,023
-

▼5,028
-

▼5,043
-

▼5,108
-

877703

2021-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,018
-

▼5,023
-

▼5,033
-

▼5,108
-

922055

2022-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold First Strike David Hall Signature

DCAM
+

10,000
-

904320

2022-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold Advanced Release Stephanie Sabin

DCAM
+

11,000
-

919399

2023-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,033
-

▼5,038
-

▼5,078
-

▼5,183
-

935945

2024-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

▼5,013
-

▼5,018
-

▼5,083
-

985161

2025-W $50 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold First Day of Issue David Hall PCGS

DCAM
+

15,000
-

$5 Gold Buffalos, PR

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

138

Type

DCAM
+

825
-

835
-

850
-

860
-

915
-

950
-

399932

2008-W $5 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

825
-

835
-

850
-

860
-

915
-

950
-

$10 Gold Buffalos, PR

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

139

Type

DCAM
+

900
-

925
-

1,000
-

1,250
-

1,400
-

1,500
-

399934

2008-W $10 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

1,350
-

1,360
-

1,425
-

2,250
-

$25 Gold Buffalos, PR

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

399936

2008-W $25 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

DCAM
+

2,750
-

2,760
-

2,815
-

3,000
-

523801

2008-W $25 American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold Moy UHR Signature

DCAM
+

6,900
-

Gold Buffalos, SP

$50 Gold Buffalos, SP

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

400037

2008-W $50 Burnished American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

SP
+

5,250
-

5,260
-

5,325
-

5,450
-

$5 Gold Buffalos, SP

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

399926

2008-W $5 Burnished American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

SP
+

850
-

860
-

870
-

880
-

890
-

900
-

960
-

1,050
-

523803

2008-W $5 Burnished Am. Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold Moy Signature

SP
+

1,250
-

$10 Gold Buffalos, SP

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

399928

2008-W $10 Burnished American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

SP
+

1,650
-

1,660
-

1,670
-

1,680
-

1,690
-

1,750
-

1,800
-

$25 Gold Buffalos, SP

PCGS No	Description	Desig	60	62	63	64	65	66	67	68	69	70

PCGS No

Description

Desig

399930

2008-W $25 Burnished American Buffalo .9999 Fine Gold

SP
+

2,750
-

2,760
-

2,815
-

2,950
-

R-1	Common
R-2	Not So Common
R-3	Scarce
R-4	Very Scarce	(76-200 known)
R-5	Rare	(31-75 known)
R-6	Very Rare	(13-30 known)
R-7	Extremely Rare	(4-12 known)
R-8	Unique or Nearly Unique	(1-3 known)

R-1	Common	(Tens of Millions)
R-2	Not so Common	(Several Million)
R-3	Scarce	(Hundreds of Thousands)
R-4	Very Scarce	(Tens of Thousands)
R-5	Rare	(Several Thousand)
R-6	Very Rare	(Several Hundred)
R-7	Extremely Rare	(Few Tens)
R-8	Unique or Nearly Unique	(Several)

PCGS Price Guide: Gold Buffalos

Sheldon Rarity Scale

VAM Rarity Scale